Littlesat,
I already explained the argument but, again, I will try to summarize them:
- I use quite often the Menu key into the channel list to create favorites, add parental control, create alternate, ... all the option that are in the channel list "option" menu.
So watching a channel I expect to press up or down and then menu to perform action on the currently watched channel. The current way of working is error prone since you are no longer on the same channel as the one you think you are if you forgot this "non ergonomics" behavior.
- When you are on the first channel of a favorite you press the up arrow you get back on the last one of the list.
- Why some action are assigned to 'strange' key in E2 (like the yellow one for example) because DM release a product with a crappy RCU with lot of button missing, so they have to find trick to implement feature on key not existing on there RCU.
- I heard that other image already fixed this behavior and people are quite happy with it.
- Believe me, you will increase the woman acceptance factor (WAF) by changing this.
Your argument to keep it this way are:
- it prevents you to press 1 key when you want to go up, I can told you that this way of working is making more click than needed since we always need to do up and down and menu to be sure to be on the right channel to perform action. But if you press the button and keep the button press you will have the same result, it will open up the channel and go to the uppers channels! So you don't lose any key press by changing this, only keypress duration.
- It works like this since 10 years.
I don't think that because it works that way since 10 years is a valid argument no to think to improve things, otherwise we will never see any evolution in it world, no GUI, no mouse, no touchscreen. Or in the windows world you can get stuck to the nice interface of Windows 2.1 forever?
http://www.jblanco.o...is/1versw2.html
Why not create a poll on the forum to ask end-user if they want or not to have a parameter for this behavior?
Moreover from my very first post I don't want to impose this behavior to everybody, i can understand that some people are used with this behavior, I just ask if it is possible to select the behavior in an easy way and I would like that on your side you also understand that this behavior can upset people that use a lot the Menu button in the channel list.
Pr2
P.S.: I just installed MQB from the feed: enigma2-plugin-extensions-multiquickbutton in the opkg it states it is 2.7 and in the GUI it states 2.4 and this 2.4 version I don't find how to change the up / down behavior (tested on VU+ Duo²). Pressing EPG no longer lead me to MultiEPG graphique due to MQB and it is not possible to define EPG short only EPG Long is foreseen.