250 replies to this topic

[Erik Slagter]

As far I know the internal 'loop' in VU boxes is made from tuner A to B... so you need to connect to tuner B to get both work....

solo2, B to A. Something with bells and whistles

[Erik Slagter]

Possible "config.isChanged()" is not working properly on this type of complex object and tuner config is not getting pushed to the settings file until reboot. None of the OE-Alliance images use isChanged() here. If the user presses save why would you want to use isChanged()?

 

https://github.com/O...tconfig.py#L592

For the moment, this indeed looks like a user interface issue rather than low level.

[littlesat]

We can consider as test to remove this isChanged check and simply save the whole crap...
But during testing back in August I did not discover an issue here... But Imsee with cancel I do also not check this...

@Erik, kan je remove that line and remove the idents for the lines below... I think I cannot do it this night and it does not harm at all..

And the position parameter ... Good point !

Edited by littlesat, 15 December 2016 - 20:23.

[Erik Slagter]

Your code It really can wait a few days, it's not a matter of life and death

[littlesat]

Indeed... And I think Huevos might be right... As configs are redefined in some cases... (New objects in configlist etc...) isChanged may not work properly...
I hope I can reach my PC later this evening...

Edited by littlesat, 15 December 2016 - 20:37.

[Eragon]

GOOD NEWS!!!

 

After removing OpenATV, restoring my OpenPLi backup, updating on-line to the latest available release...

AFAIK now JESS WORKS CORRECTLY!!

 

I believe thank to your latest update (14 dec)!

 

I repeated all the previous tests and now the 2 tuners work at the same time, whichever combination of user bands I assign to tuners, even the most extreme (user bands 14 and 16)

 

I'm attaching:

- images

- log

- My settings file Nims section

 

 

Tuner settings

 

 

 

Tuner A

 

 

 

Tuner B

 

 

http://imgur.com/a/Le7gm

config.unicable.unicable=unicable_user
config.unicable.unicableManufacturer=Dura-Sat(DUR-line)
config.unicable.unicableProduct=UK101
config.Nims.1.configMode=advanced
config.Nims.1.advanced.unicableconnectedTo=0
config.Nims.1.advanced.sats=130
config.Nims.1.advanced.sat.130.lnb=1
config.Nims.1.advanced.unicableconnected=true
config.Nims.1.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=9732
config.Nims.1.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=16
config.Nims.1.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable
config.Nims.1.advanced.lnb.1.format=jess
config.Nims.1.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Unitron-Johansson for Sky
config.Nims.1.advanced.lnb.1.scrfrequency=1940
config.Nims.0.diseqcA=3601
config.Nims.0.diseqcB=3601
config.Nims.0.diseqcC=3601
config.Nims.0.diseqcD=3601
config.Nims.0.configMode=advanced
config.Nims.0.advanced.unicableconnectedTo=1
config.Nims.0.advanced.sats=130
config.Nims.0.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=9732
config.Nims.0.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=14
config.Nims.0.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable
config.Nims.0.advanced.lnb.1.format=jess
config.Nims.0.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Unitron-Johansson for Sky
config.Nims.0.advanced.lnb.1.scrfrequency=1810
config.Nims.0.advanced.sat.130.lnb=1 

Attached Files

•  OpenPLi_JESS_log.zip   7.48KB   7 downloads

Edited by Eragon, 15 December 2016 - 22:22.

[littlesat]

Thanks!!!

Edited by littlesat, 15 December 2016 - 23:36.

[Abu Baniaz]

As the iron is hot, is it possible for the settings file to list the Nims in numerical order? At the moment, they are not in order.

config.unicable.unicableProduct=IDLU-32UL40-UNBOO-OPP
config.unicable.unicableManufacturer=Inverto
config.Nims.1.latitude=xxxxx
config.Nims.1.diseqcMode=positioner
config.Nims.1.powerMeasurement=false
config.Nims.1.longitude=xxxxx
config.Nims.1.longitudeOrientation=west
config.Nims.0.configMode=advanced
config.Nims.0.advanced.sats=282
config.Nims.0.advanced.sat.282.lnb=1
config.Nims.0.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=IDLU-32UL40-UNBOO-OPP
config.Nims.0.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Inverto
config.Nims.0.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=1
config.Nims.0.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable
config.Nims.3.configMode=advanced
config.Nims.3.advanced.unicableconnectedTo=2
config.Nims.3.advanced.unicableconnected=true
config.Nims.3.advanced.sat.282.lnb=1
config.Nims.3.advanced.sats=282
config.Nims.3.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=IDLU-32UL40-UNBOO-OPP
config.Nims.3.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Inverto
config.Nims.3.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=4
config.Nims.3.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable
config.Nims.2.configMode=advanced
config.Nims.2.advanced.unicableconnectedTo=0
config.Nims.2.advanced.unicableconnected=true
config.Nims.2.advanced.sat.282.lnb=1
config.Nims.2.advanced.sats=282
config.Nims.2.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=IDLU-32UL40-UNBOO-OPP
config.Nims.2.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Inverto
config.Nims.2.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=3
config.Nims.2.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable
config.Nims.5.configMode=advanced
config.Nims.5.advanced.unicableconnectedTo=4
config.Nims.5.advanced.unicableconnected=true
config.Nims.5.advanced.sat.282.lnb=1
config.Nims.5.advanced.sats=282
config.Nims.5.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=IDLU-32UL40-UNBOO-OPP
config.Nims.5.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Inverto
config.Nims.5.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=6
config.Nims.5.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable
config.Nims.4.configMode=advanced
config.Nims.4.advanced.unicableconnectedTo=3
config.Nims.4.advanced.unicableconnected=true
config.Nims.4.advanced.sat.282.lnb=1
config.Nims.4.advanced.sats=282
config.Nims.4.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=IDLU-32UL40-UNBOO-OPP
config.Nims.4.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Inverto
config.Nims.4.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=5
config.Nims.4.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable
config.Nims.7.configMode=advanced
config.Nims.7.advanced.unicableconnectedTo=6
config.Nims.7.advanced.unicableconnected=true
config.Nims.7.advanced.sat.282.lnb=1
config.Nims.7.advanced.sats=282
config.Nims.7.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=IDLU-32UL40-UNBOO-OPP
config.Nims.7.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Inverto
config.Nims.7.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=8
config.Nims.7.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable
config.Nims.6.configMode=advanced
config.Nims.6.advanced.unicableconnectedTo=5
config.Nims.6.advanced.unicableconnected=true
config.Nims.6.advanced.sat.282.lnb=1
config.Nims.6.advanced.sats=282
config.Nims.6.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=IDLU-32UL40-UNBOO-OPP
config.Nims.6.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Inverto
config.Nims.6.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=7
config.Nims.6.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable

This would be better

config.Nims.0.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable
config.Nims.0.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=1
config.Nims.0.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Inverto
config.Nims.0.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=IDLU-32UL40-UNBOO-OPP
config.Nims.0.advanced.sat.282.lnb=1
config.Nims.0.advanced.sats=282
config.Nims.0.configMode=advanced
config.Nims.1.diseqcMode=positioner
config.Nims.1.latitude=xxxxx
config.Nims.1.longitude=xxxxx
config.Nims.1.longitudeOrientation=west
config.Nims.1.powerMeasurement=false
config.Nims.2.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable
config.Nims.2.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=3
config.Nims.2.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Inverto
config.Nims.2.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=IDLU-32UL40-UNBOO-OPP
config.Nims.2.advanced.sat.282.lnb=1
config.Nims.2.advanced.sats=282
config.Nims.2.advanced.unicableconnected=true
config.Nims.2.advanced.unicableconnectedTo=0
config.Nims.2.configMode=advanced
config.Nims.3.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable
config.Nims.3.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=4
config.Nims.3.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Inverto
config.Nims.3.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=IDLU-32UL40-UNBOO-OPP
config.Nims.3.advanced.sat.282.lnb=1
config.Nims.3.advanced.sats=282
config.Nims.3.advanced.unicableconnected=true
config.Nims.3.advanced.unicableconnectedTo=2
config.Nims.3.configMode=advanced
config.Nims.4.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable
config.Nims.4.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=5
config.Nims.4.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Inverto
config.Nims.4.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=IDLU-32UL40-UNBOO-OPP
config.Nims.4.advanced.sat.282.lnb=1
config.Nims.4.advanced.sats=282
config.Nims.4.advanced.unicableconnected=true
config.Nims.4.advanced.unicableconnectedTo=3
config.Nims.4.configMode=advanced
config.Nims.5.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable
config.Nims.5.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=6
config.Nims.5.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Inverto
config.Nims.5.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=IDLU-32UL40-UNBOO-OPP
config.Nims.5.advanced.sat.282.lnb=1
config.Nims.5.advanced.sats=282
config.Nims.5.advanced.unicableconnected=true
config.Nims.5.advanced.unicableconnectedTo=4
config.Nims.5.configMode=advanced
config.Nims.6.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable
config.Nims.6.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=7
config.Nims.6.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Inverto
config.Nims.6.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=IDLU-32UL40-UNBOO-OPP
config.Nims.6.advanced.sat.282.lnb=1
config.Nims.6.advanced.sats=282
config.Nims.6.advanced.unicableconnected=true
config.Nims.6.advanced.unicableconnectedTo=5
config.Nims.6.configMode=advanced
config.Nims.7.advanced.lnb.1.lof=unicable
config.Nims.7.advanced.lnb.1.scrList=8
config.Nims.7.advanced.lnb.1.unicableManufacturer=Inverto
config.Nims.7.advanced.lnb.1.unicableProduct=IDLU-32UL40-UNBOO-OPP
config.Nims.7.advanced.sat.282.lnb=1
config.Nims.7.advanced.sats=282
config.Nims.7.advanced.unicableconnected=true
config.Nims.7.advanced.unicableconnectedTo=6
config.Nims.7.configMode=advanced

Thanks in advance

[athoik]

cat settings|sort

[littlesat]

the setting file was not designed to make human frendly...

I suggest reordering configs for the setting file can only be arrange at the place the configs are saved...

Edited by littlesat, 16 December 2016 - 07:48.

[Erik Slagter]

cat settings|sort

LOL, that's exactly what I do

[Erik Slagter]

the setting file was not designed to make human frendly...

I suggest reordering configs for the setting file can only be arrange at the place the configs are saved...

We might add a sorting step just before saving. I would like that.

[Erik Slagter]

@Eragon thanks for testing and yes I am very happy it worked out, thx Littlesat.

[littlesat]

We might add a sorting step just before saving. I would like that. -> +1... but this is not related to JESS...

Should we still consider to remove the check isChanged to the config.....? As far I could see during 'dry' testing everything was saved... All fields that are possibly not stored I covered with the always_save option (or so)... (remember the two lines you commented out and I could remove....)...

 

I suggest we should change this later when we have evidence and/or a scenario when something in the config is not saved instead of 'blindly' lift something without solving a real cause.
 

Edited by littlesat, 16 December 2016 - 09:43.

[Rob van der Does]

the setting file was not designed to make human frendly...

I suggest reordering configs for the setting file can only be arrange at the place the configs are saved...

We might add a sorting step just before saving. I would like that.

Good idea!

[littlesat]

Indeed....

Edited by littlesat, 16 December 2016 - 09:53.

[littlesat]

As far I can see sorting the configs keys in settings seems to be east... Untested, just by analyzing the code

 

Line 1688 in Components/config.py

 

change:

 

for (key, val) in topickle.items():

 

to:

 

for (key, val) in sorted(topickle.items()):

 

 

Probably someone can try.... as this might be an easy but good improvement....

[Erik Slagter]

Looks exactly the way I would do it in perl (which I do have knowledge of, as opposed to python...) I don't think a custom sorting comparison function is needed.

Edited by Erik Slagter, 16 December 2016 - 10:26.

[Huevos]

What did you find?

[Abu Baniaz]

I tried on OpenVix as that is what is now on the machine. Yes the items are sorted, thanks.

However, "config.Nims" comes before "config.audio"